First floor creaking and bounce in floorboards
I own an 18 month old house which we’ve had no end of issues with. Ever since we moved in the flooring in the first floor has creaked. The builder has sent their maintenance people out to fix the same spot 3 times now but the problem persists. The maintenance people say the issue is with a type of screw the NHBC make them use and their answer is to take the screws out and replace them. I’ve also noticed that some of the flooring in the bedroom is bouncy when walked on and the built in cupboard door on that spot now gets stuck on the doorframe as it’s opened. The same maintenance people have suggested this is because this is where the end of the bed is and it’s caused the floor to sag – these are the people the builder is trusting to determine what’s wrong with my floor. Even I know that a floor on a house should stand up to the corner of the bed which leads me to question their expertise. The bounciness and creaking are evident all over the first floor, What is the possible cause of this and who would I need to inspect it to get a definitive answer? Thank you
=============================
Answer:-
The symptoms you’re describing – persistent creaking, bouncy floors, and structural movement causing doors to stick – suggest more serious structural issues than simple screw problems. The maintenance team’s explanations are concerning and don’t address the root causes.
Possible underlying causes:
The bouncy, creaking floors likely indicate problems with the floor joist system. This could involve undersized joists for the span, improper spacing, inadequate bridging between joists, or issues with how the joists are supported at the walls. If there’s sagging severe enough to affect door alignment, it suggests the floor structure isn’t adequately supporting normal loads – which should absolutely include furniture like beds.
The subfloor attachment could also be problematic. While screws vs. nails can affect creaking, persistent issues after multiple “fixes” suggest either improper fastening patterns, inadequate subfloor thickness, or movement in the underlying structure that no fastener will solve.
Who should inspect:
You need an independent structural engineer – not someone affiliated with the builder. A qualified structural engineer can assess whether the floor framing meets building codes and design standards. They’ll examine joist sizing, spacing, spans, support conditions, and subfloor attachment.
Given this is an 18-month-old home with persistent issues, also contact NHBC directly. They have technical standards for floor construction and can investigate whether the work meets their requirements. Document everything and consider getting a second opinion before the builder attempts more “fixes” that don’t address the underlying structural adequacy.
The fact that normal furniture placement is being blamed for structural problems is a red flag that suggests the floor system may be inadequately designed or constructed.

