9m Steel Ground Floor To Support Upstairs And Loft
Hello, I am looking at getting a downstairs extension and the original aim was to remove a load bearing column supporting the upstairs and expand to the side. I have received mixed information as to whether a proposed 8.5m steel would still need to be supported centrally by a load bearing column. The ‘yes you can’ to the ‘you probably cannot’ has come from two different designers who are both confident there Structural Engineer will support them. Obviously I don’t want to commit and agree to a design if it’s not actually possible! To add to the build challenge, the 8.5m Steel would need to connect to another 3.5m Steel, in effective causing a T shaped style connection. Is it common in the building industry to do such a thing without having a load bearing column? My concern is that with the size and weight of the steels in question, we would need a load bearing wall near where those two steels join. Also, Is it possible to have one Structural Engineer say it’s not feasible and another stating that it’s fine? Do they all comply with the same rules, or is it entirely possible that speaking to two different Structural Engineers would render completely different results? How do I ensure that I don’t choose a Structural Engineer that is an ‘outlier’ or who chooses ‘to go rogue’ in this circumstance? My sole priority here is safety first, design second. I don’t want anything to collapse, crack, droop or sink over time. Many thanks in advance.
=======================
Answer-
This is an important structural engineering question that requires careful consideration. Here are my thoughts on the key points you’ve raised:
1. Feasibility of an 8.5m unsupported steel beam:
It is possible to have an 8.5m steel beam without central support, but it depends on several factors:
– The load it needs to carry (floor, walls, roof above)
– The depth and type of steel beam used
– The connections at each end
– Any additional reinforcement or design features
2. T-shaped connection:
Connecting an 8.5m beam to a 3.5m beam in a T-shape without support is more complex. This junction would experience significant stress and would need very careful engineering design.
3. Variation in structural engineer opinions:
While structural engineers follow the same basic principles and building codes, there can be differences in:
– Interpretation of codes
– Design approaches
– Risk tolerance
– Calculation methods used
It’s not uncommon for engineers to have differing opinions, especially on complex or unusual designs.
4. Ensuring safety and reliability:
To ensure you get a safe and reliable design:
a) Seek multiple opinions: Get at least 2-3 independent structural engineer assessments.
b) Ask for detailed calculations: Any proposal should be backed by comprehensive structural calculations.
c) Check qualifications: Ensure the engineers are properly qualified and registered with relevant professional bodies.
d) Local authority approval: Remember that any major structural work will need approval from your local building control department. They provide an additional safety check.
e) Consider peer review: For complex designs, you might want to have one engineer’s work reviewed by another.
f) Err on the side of caution: If in doubt, opt for the more conservative design approach.
5. Long-term considerations:
You’re right to be concerned about long-term performance. Factors to consider include:
– Potential for settlement or movement over time
– Impact of removing load-bearing elements on the rest of the structure
– Future flexibility of the space
Given the complexity of your project and the conflicting advice you’ve received, I would strongly recommend getting additional independent structural engineering opinions. Look for engineers with specific experience in residential renovations and beam designs of this scale.
==========================
Contact Us :
(0)20 3987 4923
Mob: 07404960364
info@vrltd.uk
566 Chiswick High Street, W4 5YA, London

