Is it our fault that our wet room failed after 8 years?
We had a wet room installed in our loft conversion in 2014. Basically a fully tiled room with shower and toilet, with no shower tray or cubicle, but tiles on the floor angled down to the trap in the shower area. i.e. you stand on the tiles when you’re having a shower. Apparently, the floor tiles were fitted onto Marmox board. It was all installed by the loft conversion company who were very reputable and excellent in every other respect. They gave us a 10 year guarantee on the work. I first started noticing the floor tiles in the shower area moving slightly during 2022. Then later in the year it became obvious there was water coming slowly through the ceiling of the room below. Long story short, the loft conversion company say only ‘structural’ faults are covered in the guarantee and they regard this as a maintenance issue caused by us not getting the grouting and silicone redone regularly. The initial idea of the wet room was mine, but I didn’t push them on it and they didn’t suggest there would be any problem with it. They certainly didn’t say we’d need to get the silicone and grouting redone frequently and we’d never have gone for this if we’d known. We’ve been quoted (by another company) £2500 + VAT + materials to get the floor retiled and sorted out, so about £3500 all in. It’s to remove the floor tiles, and bottom row of wall tiles, sort the flooring, install a shower tray and door and retile. So – would be interested to know if people think we just have to suck this one up and whether the quote seems fair. Thanks in advance.
=========================
Answer:-
Based on your description, I don’t think this is your fault, and you have grounds to challenge the loft conversion company’s position. Here’s why:
Why this likely isn’t your fault:
The failure after 8 years suggests a fundamental design or installation issue rather than maintenance neglect. Proper wet room installations should last much longer than this with normal use and reasonable maintenance. The fact that tiles were moving and water was penetrating to the ceiling below indicates waterproofing failure – this is typically a structural/installation issue, not maintenance.
Key points in your favor:
- You weren’t advised about frequent regrouting/silicone maintenance requirements upfront
- A reputable installer should have either warned you about high maintenance needs or designed a more durable system
- 8 years is too short a lifespan for a properly installed wet room
- The 10-year guarantee should reasonably cover waterproofing failures
Regarding the quote:
£3,500 seems reasonable for the extensive work described (removing tiles, waterproofing repairs, installing shower tray/door, retiling). This is actually addressing the fundamental design issue by adding a proper shower tray rather than relying solely on tiled waterproofing.
My suggestions:
- Push back harder with the original company – consider involving trading standards or small claims court
- Get a building surveyor’s report on the failure cause
- Check if you have home insurance coverage
- Consider getting a second quote for comparison
==========================
Contact Us :
(0)20 3987 4923
Mob: 07404960364
info@vrltd.uk
566 Chiswick High Street, W4 5YA, London

